Ekur: Difference between revisions

From All Skies Encyclopaedia
 
(6 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
an ancient Mesopotamian super-constellation consisting of the group of the Standing Gods of the Ekur (<sup>mul</sup>[[DINGIR.GUB.BA|DIĜIR.GUB.BA<sup>meš</sup>]] ) and the Sitting Gods of the Ekur ( <sup>mul</sup>[[DINGIR.KU.A|DIĜIR.TUŠ.A]]<sup>meš</sup>), both mentioned in MUL.APIN.
The Ekur (''E<sub>2</sub>-kur'') is an ancient Mesopotamian super-constellation consisting of the group of the Standing Gods of the Ekur (<sup>mul</sup>[[DINGIR.GUB.BA|DIĜIR.GUB.BA<sup>meš</sup>]]) and the Sitting Gods of the Ekur (<sup>mul</sup>[[DINGIR.KU.A|DIĜIR.TUŠ.A]]<sup>meš</sup>), both mentioned in MUL.APIN.


==Dictionary (Provenance of the term)==
==Dictionary (Provenance of the term)==
=== Krebernik (2023) ===
=== Krebernik (2023) ===
see glossary of Hoffmann and Krebernik (2023):<ref>Hoffmann, S. M. and Krebernik, M. (2023). What do deities tell us about the celestial positioning system, in: R. Rollinger, I. Madreiter, M. Lang, C. Pappi (eds.). The Intellectual Heritage of the Ancient Near East, Papers held at the 64th Rencontre Assyriologique International and 12th Melammu Symposium July 16-20 2018, Innsbruck. Austrian Academy of Sciences Press, 539-579</ref>
see glossary of Hoffmann and Krebernik (2023):<ref name=":0">Hoffmann, S. M. and Krebernik, M. (2023). What do deities tell us about the celestial positioning system, in: R. Rollinger, I. Madreiter, M. Lang, C. Pappi (eds.). The Intellectual Heritage of the Ancient Near East, Papers held at the 64th Rencontre Assyriologique International and 12th Melammu Symposium July 16-20 2018, Innsbruck. Austrian Academy of Sciences Press, 539-579</ref>


<sup>mul</sup>DIĜIR.GUB.BA<sup>meš</sup> & <sup>mul</sup>DIĜIR.TUŠ.A<sup>meš</sup>. The sumerograms are ambiguous, since the first sign can be read as DIĜIR “god” or AN “heaven”, and TUŠ can also be read DÚR (both meaning “to sit”) or KU. However, the addition of A makes the reading TUŠ virtually certain. In the same manner, BA confirms the reading of GUB.BA. The Sum. forms mean “seated, sitting” and “standing”, respectively.
<sup>mul</sup>DIĜIR.GUB.BA<sup>meš</sup> & <sup>mul</sup>DIĜIR.TUŠ.A<sup>meš</sup>. The sumerograms are ambiguous, since the first sign can be read as DIĜIR “god” or AN “heaven”, and TUŠ can also be read DÚR (both meaning “to sit”) or KU. However, the addition of A makes the reading TUŠ virtually certain. In the same manner, BA confirms the reading of GUB.BA. The Sum. forms mean “seated, sitting” and “standing”, respectively.


The corresponding entries in the dictionaries are angubbû (AHw, CAD) and ''ankurû'' (CAD), ''antušû'' (AHw), respectively. The first sumerogram, which is much more common than the second, designates a type of priest and describes the function of certain (minor) deities in god lists. In the OB Ištar ritual from Mari, the DIĜIR<sup>meš</sup> DIĜIR-''gub-bu-ú'' are obviously (representations of) deities, who “sit down to the left of Ištar together with (the god) Latarak” (ii 1’-3’, see Ziegler 1997, 58). The usage in MUL.APIN, where the two expressions are connected with Enlil’s temple Ekur in Nippur (“The stars of the Standing/Sitting Gods of the Ekur”) seems to be comparable. In 5R 46: 15–16., the “Standing Gods of the Ekur” are interpreted as “Sîn and Nergal”, and the “Sitting Gods” as “Anu and Enlil”, which is not applicable to MUL.APIN. The same is true of [M]UL.DIĜIR.GUB].BA<sup>meš</sup> DIĜIR.TUŠ.A<sup>meš</sup> in Hg, where they are identified with Sîn and Šamaš (MSL 11, 41: 52). MUL.DIĜIR.GUB.BA<sup>meš</sup> ''šu-ut'' É.KUR / MUL.DIĜIR.TUŠ.A<sup>meš</sup> ''šu-ut'' É.KUR (after EN 21).
The corresponding entries in the dictionaries are angubbû (AHw, CAD) and ''ankurû'' (CAD), ''antušû'' (AHw), respectively. The first sumerogram, which is much more common than the second, designates a type of priest and describes the function of certain (minor) deities in god lists. In the OB Ištar ritual from Mari, the DIĜIR<sup>meš</sup> DIĜIR-''gub-bu-ú'' are obviously (representations of) deities, who “sit down to the left of Ištar together with (the god) Latarak” (ii 1’-3’, see Ziegler 1997, 58). The usage in MUL.APIN, where the two expressions are connected with Enlil’s temple Ekur in Nippur (“The stars of the Standing/Sitting Gods of the Ekur”) seems to be comparable. In 5R 46: 15–16., the “Standing Gods of the Ekur” are interpreted as “Sîn and Nergal”, and the “Sitting Gods” as “Anu and Enlil”, which is not applicable to MUL.APIN. The same is true of [M]UL.DIĜIR.GUB].BA<sup>meš</sup> DIĜIR.TUŠ.A<sup>meš</sup> in Hg, where they are identified with Sîn and Šamaš (MSL 11, 41: 52). MUL.DIĜIR.GUB.BA<sup>meš</sup> ''šu-ut'' É.KUR / MUL.DIĜIR.TUŠ.A<sup>meš</sup> ''šu-ut'' É.KUR (after EN 21).
=== Kurtik with Hilder, Hoffmann, Horowitz, Kim ===


==== Hoffmann and Krebernik Text Edition ====
The path of Enlil in MUL.APIN<ref name=":0" />
{| class="wikitable"
!our numbering
!DIŠ
!explanandum
!explanans
|-
|1
|1
|<sup>STAR</sup>EPINNU (Plough)
|<sup>GOD</sup>Enlil
|-
|2
|1
|<sup>STAR</sup>BARBARU (Wolf)
|seeder of <sup>STAR</sup>EPINNU
|-
|3
|1
|<sup>STAR</sup>ŠĪBU (Old Man)
|<sup>GOD</sup>Enmešarra
|-
|4
|<1>
|<sup>STAR</sup>GAMLU (Throwing-stick)
|<sup>GOD</sup>Gamlum(Throwing-stick)
|-
|5–6
|1
|<sup>STAR</sup>TŪ’AMŪ·RABÛTU (Great Twins)
|<sup>GOD</sup>Lugalirra and <sup>GOD</sup>Meslamtaʾea
|-
|7–8
|1
|<sup>STAR</sup>TŪ’AMŪ·ṢEḪRŪTU (Little Twins)
|<sup>GOD</sup>Alammuš and <sup>GOD</sup>Ningublaga
|-
|9
|1
|<sup>STAR</sup>ALLUTTU (Crab)
|seat of <sup>GOD</sup>Anu
|-
|10
|1
|<sup>STAR</sup>URGULÛ (Lion)
|<sup>GOD</sup>Latarak
|-
|11
|1
|STAR opposite <sup>STAR</sup>URGULÛ
|STAR (of the) King
|-
|12
|1
|twinkling STARs in the tail of <sup>STAR</sup>URGULÛ
|‘date-palm spadix’ (jewellery?) (of) <sup>GOD</sup><nowiki>Erua | </nowiki><sup>GOD</sup>Zarpanītum
|-
|13
|1
|<sup>STAR</sup>ŠU.PA (The Bright?)
|<sup>GOD</sup>Enlil who determines the destinies of the land
|-
|14
|1
|STAR in front of it: <sup>STAR</sup>ḪENGALLĀYU (Abundant)
|vizier of <sup>GOD</sup>Ninlil
|-
|15
|1
|STAR behind it: <sup>STAR</sup>BĀŠTUM(Dignity)
|vizier of <sup>GOD</sup>Tišpak(<*INANNA!?)
|-
|16
|1
|<sup>STAR</sup>EREQQU (Wagon)
|<sup>GOD</sup>Ninlil
|-
|17
|1
|STAR by the pole of <sup>STAR</sup>EREQQU: <sup>STAR</sup>ŠĒLEBU(Fox)
|<sup>GOD</sup>Erra, the  strong of the gods
|-
|18
|1
|STAR on the forehead of <sup>STAR</sup>EREQQU: <sup>STAR</sup>LAḪRU(Ewe)
|<sup>GOD</sup>Aya
|-
|19
|1
|<sup>STAR</sup>MU.BU.KÉŠ.DA (Hitched yoke?)
|<sup>GOD</sup>Anu-rabû of heaven
|-
|20
|1
|<sup>STAR</sup>MAR.GÍD.DA.AN.NA (Wagon of heaven)
|<sup>GOD</sup>Damkianna
|-
|21
|1
|STAR in its bond: <sup>STAR</sup>APIL-EMAḪ (Heir of the Emaḫ-temple)
|foremost son of <sup>GOD</sup>Anu
|-
!
!{1}
!STAR·STANDING·GOD<sup>s</sup> of the Ekur
!The stars (of the) Standing Gods of the Ekur
|-
!
!({1})
!STAR·SITTING·GOD<sup>s</sup> of the Ekur
!Sitting Gods of the Ekur (temple)
|-
|22
|1
|<sup>STAR</sup>ENZU (She-Goat)
|<sup>GOD</sup>Gula
|-
|23
|1
|STAR in front of <sup>STAR</sup>ENZU
|<sup>STAR</sup>KALBU(Dog) (of <sup>GOD</sup>Gula)
|-
|24
|1
|bright STAR of <sup>STAR</sup>ENZU
|<sup>GOD</sup><nowiki>Lamassatu | vizier of </nowiki><sup>GOD</sup>Baba (= <sup>GOD</sup>Gu-la)
|-
|25–26
|1
|2 STAR<sup>s</sup> behind it
|<sup>GOD</sup>Nin-SAR and <sup>GOD</sup>Errakal
|-
|27
|1
|<sup>STAR</sup>U<sub>4</sub>.KA.DU<sub>8</sub>.A
|<sup>GOD</sup>U.GUR(Nergal)
|-
|28
|1
|STAR to the right of it
|<sup>STAR</sup><nowiki>ŠAḪÛ(Pig) | </nowiki><sup>GOD</sup>Damu
|-
|29
|1
|STAR to the left of it
|<sup>STARS</sup>SISÛ(Horse)
|-
|30
|1
|STAR behind it
|<sup>STAR</sup><nowiki>LULIMMU | vizier of STAR.STAR (Pleiades)</nowiki>
|-
|31
|1
|twinkling STAR<sup>s</sup> opposite <sup>STAR</sup>LULIMMU(Stag)
|<sup>GOD</sup><nowiki>Ḫarriru (Field Mouse) | </nowiki><sup>GOD</sup>Manzât(Rainbow)
|-
|32
|1
|red bright STAR in the kidney of <sup>STAR</sup>LULIMMU
|<sup>STAR</sup>PĀŠITTU (Deleter)
|-
!
!
! colspan="2" |When the STAR<sup>s</sup> of <sup>GOD</sup>Enlil are completed:
|}
The Standing Gods and the Sitting Gods are rubric markers (like headlines in modern texts). Then, the rest of the list can be rendered as itemized lists in modern text layout.<ref name=":1" />
{| class="wikitable"
|+
!
!explanandum
!explanans
|-
!Standing Gods of the Ekur
|
* Plough
** Wolf
* Old Man
* Throwing Stick
* Great Twins
* Little Twins
* Crab
* Lion
** King
** Date-Palm Spadix
* Shupa
*
|
* Enlil
** .
* Enmesharra
* Gamlu
* Lugalirra and Meslamta'ea
* Alamush and Ningublaga
* Anu
* Latarak
** .
** Zarpanitum
* Enlil
*
|-
!Sitting Gods of the Ekur
|
*Wagon
** Fox
** Ewe
* Hitched Yoke
* Wagon of Heaven
* Heir
|
*Ninlil
** Erra
** Aya
* Anu
* Damkianna
* Anu
|-
!Outside the Ekur
|
* She-Goat
** Dog
** Lamassatu
** two stars
* UD.KA.DU<sub>8</sub>.A
** Pig
** Horse
** Stag
*** Field Mouse
*** Deleter
|
* Gula
** .
** Lamassatu
** Ninsar and Erragal
* UD.KA.DU<sub>8</sub>.A
** Damu
** .
** .
*** Manzat (Rainbow)
*** Pashittu
|}

=== Kurtik with Hilder, Hoffmann, Horowitz, Kim ===
{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"


Line 19: Line 262:
**"Standing Gods of the Ekur" (I i 23),
**"Standing Gods of the Ekur" (I i 23),
**for a parallel see. [Horowitz 1989-90, 116, BM 54817:10'].
**for a parallel see. [Horowitz 1989-90, 116, BM 54817:10'].
| [[File:EkurGodsSchema on stellarium txt.jpg|thumb|The constellations of "The Ekur" in Stellarium and a schema overlay: The Sitting Gods are bluish, and the Standing Gods are darker gray. The two additional Non-Ekur divine "entities" with their entourage (Susanne M Hoffmann 2025).]]
| rowspan="2" | [[File:EkurGodsSchema on stellarium txt.jpg|thumb|The constellations of "The Ekur" in Stellarium and a schema overlay: The Sitting Gods are bluish, and the Standing Gods are darker gray. The two additional Non-Ekur divine "entities" with their entourage (Susanne M Hoffmann 2025).]]
|-
|-
| '''MUL.APIN.'''
| '''MUL.APIN.'''
*The list of the stars of Enlil (no. 22): <sup>mul</sup>DINGIR.TUŠ.A<sup>meš</sup> ''šu-ut E''<sub>2</sub>''-kur'' "Sitting Gods of Ekur" (I i 23), see also [Horowitz 1989-90, 116, BM 54817:10'].
*The list of the stars of Enlil (no. 22): <sup>mul</sup>DINGIR.TUŠ.A<sup>meš</sup> ''šu-ut E''<sub>2</sub>''-kur'' "Sitting Gods of Ekur" (I i 23), see also [Horowitz 1989-90, 116, BM 54817:10'].
| [[File:EkurGodsSchema on stellarium txt.jpg|thumb|The MUL.APIN-"The Ekur" in Stellarium and a schema overlay: The Sitting Gods are bluish, and the Standing Gods are darker gray. The two additional Non-Ekur divine "entities" with their entourage (Susanne M Hoffmann 2025).]]
|}
|}


Line 49: Line 291:


== Historical Dictionaries ==
== Historical Dictionaries ==
The historical dictionaries by Kurtik (2007) and Gössmann (1950) both don't include this term, as the discovery of the astronomical unit of The Ekur only happened in a series of papers later (Hoffmann and Krebernik 2023,<ref>Hoffmann, S. M. and Krebernik, M. (2023). What do deities tell us about the celestial positioning system, in: R. Rollinger, I. Madreiter, M. Lang, C. Pappi (eds.). The Intellectual Heritage of the Ancient Near East, Papers held at the 64th Rencontre Assyriologique International and 12th Melammu Symposium July 16-20 2018, Innsbruck. Austrian Academy of Sciences Press, 539-579</ref> Hoffmann and Horowitz 2023,<ref>Hoffmann and Horowitz (2023). The Standing and Sitting Asterisms of Ekur, N.A.B.U., n°3 (sept.), 141-143</ref> and Hoffmann 2024<ref>Hoffmann, S.M. (2024): Standing and Sitting Gods of MUL.APIN, Journal of Astronomical History and Heritage, 27(2), 261-272</ref>)
The historical dictionaries by Kurtik (2007) and Gössmann (1950) both don't include this term, as the discovery of the astronomical unit of The Ekur only happened in a series of papers later (Hoffmann and Krebernik 2023,<ref name=":0" /> Hoffmann and Horowitz 2023,<ref>Hoffmann and Horowitz (2023). The Standing and Sitting Asterisms of Ekur, N.A.B.U., n°3 (sept.), 141-143</ref> and Hoffmann 2024<ref name=":1">Hoffmann, S.M. (2024): Standing and Sitting Gods of MUL.APIN, Journal of Astronomical History and Heritage, 27(2), 261-272</ref>)


== References ==
== References ==

Latest revision as of 22:42, 16 June 2025

The Ekur (E2-kur) is an ancient Mesopotamian super-constellation consisting of the group of the Standing Gods of the Ekur (mulDIĜIR.GUB.BAmeš) and the Sitting Gods of the Ekur (mulDIĜIR.TUŠ.Ameš), both mentioned in MUL.APIN.

Dictionary (Provenance of the term)

Krebernik (2023)

see glossary of Hoffmann and Krebernik (2023):[1]

mulDIĜIR.GUB.BAmeš & mulDIĜIR.TUŠ.Ameš. The sumerograms are ambiguous, since the first sign can be read as DIĜIR “god” or AN “heaven”, and TUŠ can also be read DÚR (both meaning “to sit”) or KU. However, the addition of A makes the reading TUŠ virtually certain. In the same manner, BA confirms the reading of GUB.BA. The Sum. forms mean “seated, sitting” and “standing”, respectively.

The corresponding entries in the dictionaries are angubbû (AHw, CAD) and ankurû (CAD), antušû (AHw), respectively. The first sumerogram, which is much more common than the second, designates a type of priest and describes the function of certain (minor) deities in god lists. In the OB Ištar ritual from Mari, the DIĜIRmeš DIĜIR-gub-bu-ú are obviously (representations of) deities, who “sit down to the left of Ištar together with (the god) Latarak” (ii 1’-3’, see Ziegler 1997, 58). The usage in MUL.APIN, where the two expressions are connected with Enlil’s temple Ekur in Nippur (“The stars of the Standing/Sitting Gods of the Ekur”) seems to be comparable. In 5R 46: 15–16., the “Standing Gods of the Ekur” are interpreted as “Sîn and Nergal”, and the “Sitting Gods” as “Anu and Enlil”, which is not applicable to MUL.APIN. The same is true of [M]UL.DIĜIR.GUB].BAmeš DIĜIR.TUŠ.Ameš in Hg, where they are identified with Sîn and Šamaš (MSL 11, 41: 52). MUL.DIĜIR.GUB.BAmeš šu-ut É.KUR / MUL.DIĜIR.TUŠ.Ameš šu-ut É.KUR (after EN 21).

Hoffmann and Krebernik Text Edition

The path of Enlil in MUL.APIN[1]

our numbering DIŠ explanandum explanans
1 1 STAREPINNU (Plough) GODEnlil
2 1 STARBARBARU (Wolf) seeder of STAREPINNU
3 1 STARŠĪBU (Old Man) GODEnmešarra
4 <1> STARGAMLU (Throwing-stick) GODGamlum(Throwing-stick)
5–6 1 STARTŪ’AMŪ·RABÛTU (Great Twins) GODLugalirra and GODMeslamtaʾea
7–8 1 STARTŪ’AMŪ·ṢEḪRŪTU (Little Twins) GODAlammuš and GODNingublaga
9 1 STARALLUTTU (Crab) seat of GODAnu
10 1 STARURGULÛ (Lion) GODLatarak
11 1 STAR opposite STARURGULÛ STAR (of the) King
12 1 twinkling STARs in the tail of STARURGULÛ ‘date-palm spadix’ (jewellery?) (of) GODErua | GODZarpanītum
13 1 STARŠU.PA (The Bright?) GODEnlil who determines the destinies of the land
14 1 STAR in front of it: STARḪENGALLĀYU (Abundant) vizier of GODNinlil
15 1 STAR behind it: STARBĀŠTUM(Dignity) vizier of GODTišpak(<*INANNA!?)
16 1 STAREREQQU (Wagon) GODNinlil
17 1 STAR by the pole of STAREREQQU: STARŠĒLEBU(Fox) GODErra, the  strong of the gods
18 1 STAR on the forehead of STAREREQQU: STARLAḪRU(Ewe) GODAya
19 1 STARMU.BU.KÉŠ.DA (Hitched yoke?) GODAnu-rabû of heaven
20 1 STARMAR.GÍD.DA.AN.NA (Wagon of heaven) GODDamkianna
21 1 STAR in its bond: STARAPIL-EMAḪ (Heir of the Emaḫ-temple) foremost son of GODAnu
{1} STAR·STANDING·GODs of the Ekur The stars (of the) Standing Gods of the Ekur
({1}) STAR·SITTING·GODs of the Ekur Sitting Gods of the Ekur (temple)
22 1 STARENZU (She-Goat) GODGula
23 1 STAR in front of STARENZU STARKALBU(Dog) (of GODGula)
24 1 bright STAR of STARENZU GODLamassatu | vizier of GODBaba (= GODGu-la)
25–26 1 2 STARs behind it GODNin-SAR and GODErrakal
27 1 STARU4.KA.DU8.A GODU.GUR(Nergal)
28 1 STAR to the right of it STARŠAḪÛ(Pig) | GODDamu
29 1 STAR to the left of it STARSSISÛ(Horse)
30 1 STAR behind it STARLULIMMU | vizier of STAR.STAR (Pleiades)
31 1 twinkling STARs opposite STARLULIMMU(Stag) GODḪarriru (Field Mouse) | GODManzât(Rainbow)
32 1 red bright STAR in the kidney of STARLULIMMU STARPĀŠITTU (Deleter)
When the STARs of GODEnlil are completed:

The Standing Gods and the Sitting Gods are rubric markers (like headlines in modern texts). Then, the rest of the list can be rendered as itemized lists in modern text layout.[2]

explanandum explanans
Standing Gods of the Ekur
  • Plough
    • Wolf
  • Old Man
  • Throwing Stick
  • Great Twins
  • Little Twins
  • Crab
  • Lion
    • King
    • Date-Palm Spadix
  • Shupa
  • Enlil
    • .
  • Enmesharra
  • Gamlu
  • Lugalirra and Meslamta'ea
  • Alamush and Ningublaga
  • Anu
  • Latarak
    • .
    • Zarpanitum
  • Enlil
Sitting Gods of the Ekur
  • Wagon
    • Fox
    • Ewe
  • Hitched Yoke
  • Wagon of Heaven
  • Heir
  • Ninlil
    • Erra
    • Aya
  • Anu
  • Damkianna
  • Anu
Outside the Ekur
  • She-Goat
    • Dog
    • Lamassatu
    • two stars
  • UD.KA.DU8.A
    • Pig
    • Horse
    • Stag
      • Field Mouse
      • Deleter
  • Gula
    • .
    • Lamassatu
    • Ninsar and Erragal
  • UD.KA.DU8.A
    • Damu
    • .
    • .
      • Manzat (Rainbow)
      • Pashittu

Kurtik with Hilder, Hoffmann, Horowitz, Kim

Sources Identifications
MUL.APIN.
  • (1) The stars of Enlil (no. 21):
    • mulDINGIR.GUB.BAmeš šu-ut E2-kur
    • "Standing Gods of the Ekur" (I i 23),
    • for a parallel see. [Horowitz 1989-90, 116, BM 54817:10'].
The constellations of "The Ekur" in Stellarium and a schema overlay: The Sitting Gods are bluish, and the Standing Gods are darker gray. The two additional Non-Ekur divine "entities" with their entourage (Susanne M Hoffmann 2025).
MUL.APIN.
  • The list of the stars of Enlil (no. 22): mulDINGIR.TUŠ.Ameš šu-ut E2-kur "Sitting Gods of Ekur" (I i 23), see also [Horowitz 1989-90, 116, BM 54817:10'].

additional

Deities of the Ekur

  1. Standing Gods
    1. Enlil
    2. Enmešarra
    3. Lugalirra and Meslamtaʾea
    4. Alammuš and Ningublaga
    5. Anu
    6. Latarak
    7. Erua | Zarpanītum
    8. Enlil
  2. Sitting Gods
    1. Tišpak
    2. Ninlil and her vizier
    3. Erra
    4. Aya
    5. Anu
    6. Damkianna
    7. The Heir of the Emaḫ-temple (could be Enlil's or Anu's son)

Historical Dictionaries

The historical dictionaries by Kurtik (2007) and Gössmann (1950) both don't include this term, as the discovery of the astronomical unit of The Ekur only happened in a series of papers later (Hoffmann and Krebernik 2023,[1] Hoffmann and Horowitz 2023,[3] and Hoffmann 2024[2])

References

  1. 1.0 1.1 1.2 Hoffmann, S. M. and Krebernik, M. (2023). What do deities tell us about the celestial positioning system, in: R. Rollinger, I. Madreiter, M. Lang, C. Pappi (eds.). The Intellectual Heritage of the Ancient Near East, Papers held at the 64th Rencontre Assyriologique International and 12th Melammu Symposium July 16-20 2018, Innsbruck. Austrian Academy of Sciences Press, 539-579
  2. 2.0 2.1 Hoffmann, S.M. (2024): Standing and Sitting Gods of MUL.APIN, Journal of Astronomical History and Heritage, 27(2), 261-272
  3. Hoffmann and Horowitz (2023). The Standing and Sitting Asterisms of Ekur, N.A.B.U., n°3 (sept.), 141-143