Dorado: Difference between revisions

From All Skies Encyclopaedia
(Revised a link)
 
(21 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
[[File:DOR (IAU definition).gif|alt=DOR modern map|thumb|The modern map of the IAU-constellation Dorado (S&T graphics)]] one of the 88 official constellations. The Spanish term "dorado" means "golden", and it has been used for various type of fish in the past. Given this translation, the constellation name has sometimes been translated as "Goldfish", although the Spanish term always designated exotic fish species from the "new worlds".
[[File:DOR (IAU definition).gif|alt=DOR modern map|thumb|The modern map of the IAU-constellation Dorado (S&T graphics)]] One of the 88 official constellations. There is no need to translate the term because "Dorado" already is a modern (not Latin) word and used in many languages to designate a specific sort of fish. For further explanation, "Dorado, the Dolphinfish" would work in English. The Spanish term "dorado" literally means "golden", and it has been used for various type of fish in the past. Given this translation, the constellation name has sometimes been translated as "Goldfish", although the Spanish term always designated exotic fish species from the "new worlds".


==Etymology and History==
==Etymology and History==


Dorado, the Dolphinfish, has been invented by Pieter Keyser and Frederik de Houtman on their journey to Indonesia (later called "Dutch Indies") 1592-1594. Their catalogue of southern stars was published by de [https://objects.library.uu.nl/reader/index.php?obj=1874-205055&lan=en#page//10/65/92/106592907949460216143244254321834124579.jpg/mode/1up Houtman in 1603 as an appendix] to a dictionary of the Malaysian (and other) language(s). This star catalogue was written in Dutch and never translated. Before the publication of the star catalogue, de Houtman has shared his data with Petrus Plancius, who had actually commissioned this work. Even in the 1590s, Plancius had worked with this material and his [http://www.ianridpath.com/startales/plancius-globe.html celestial globe of 1598] already displayed paintings of the newly invented constellations in the south, and so did Johann Bayer's Uranometria (1603).
Dorado, the Dolphinfish, has been invented by Pieter Keyser and Frederik de Houtman on their journey to Indonesia (later called "Dutch Indies") 1592-1594. Their catalogue<ref>de Houtman, Frederik (1603) [https://objects.library.uu.nl/reader/index.php?obj=1874-205055&lan=en#page//10/65/92/106592907949460216143244254321834124579.jpg/mode/1up Star Catalogue in a Dictionary of Malayan language]</ref> of southern stars was published by de [https://objects.library.uu.nl/reader/index.php?obj=1874-205055&lan=en#page//10/65/92/106592907949460216143244254321834124579.jpg/mode/1up Houtman in 1603 as an appendix] to a dictionary of the Malaysian (and other) language(s). Before the publication of the star catalogue, de Houtman shared his data with Petrus Plancius, who had actually commissioned this work. Even in the 1590s, Plancius had worked with this material and his [http://www.ianridpath.com/startales/plancius-globe.html celestial globe of 1598] already displayed paintings of the newly invented constellations in the south, and so did Johann Bayer's Uranometria (1603).


===Species of Fish===
===Species of Fish===
Following Dekker (1987),<ref>Dekker, E. (1987), Early explorations of the southern celestial sky, Annals of Science, 44:5, 439-470. [[References (Medieval and Early Modern)|PDF here References (Medieval and Early Modern)]]</ref> Ridpath<ref>Ridpath, Ian * Ridpath, Ian, [http://www.ianridpath.com/startales/dorado.html Star Tales: online edition].</ref> (supported by van Gent) argues that the dorado in the sky hunts the flying fish (Volans), and that the Dutch explorer might have observed such a hunt on their journey (cf. [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bk7McNUjWgw BBC Earth documentation], also see Maas 1924<ref>Maass, Alfred, ``Sternkunde und Sterndeuterei im malaiischen Archipel<nowiki>''</nowiki>, [https://kitlv-docs.library.leiden.edu/open/Metamorfoze/TBG/tbg.html Tijdschrift voor Indische Taal-, Land- en Volkenkunde], vol. 64 (1924), pp. 1-172 & 347-459, with a "Nachtrag", vol. 66 (1926), pp. 618-670.</ref>).

Despite translating the Spanish term "dorado" (golden), historical Spanish and other European languages never designated any species of [[wikipedia:Goldfish|goldfish]] (small freshwater pet fish) with the term.
Despite translating the Spanish term "dorado" (golden), historical Spanish and other European languages never designated any species of [[wikipedia:Goldfish|goldfish]] (small freshwater pet fish) with the term.


In biology, "Dorado" is the name of two sorts of fish: a freshwater fish in South America and a predatory fish that lives in the ocean. The ocean inhabitants, who had inspired de Houtman and Keyser, are today known as dolphinfishes with the scientific genus name "Coryphaena". The "Common Dolphinfish" (''Coryphaena hippurus'') is called '''''Mahi Mahi,''''' the Hawaiian language term for "very strong". In Persian, the word "mahi" (ماهی) happens to mean "fish" which is unrelated to the Hawaiian term. Although there are other names for the fish in some regions (e.g. "Lampuka" on the Mediterranean island of Malta and specifically "Ikan Lemadang" in Indonesia, where de Houtman and Keyser invented the celestial name), the Hawaiian term became publicly known. To avoid confusion with dolphins (the sea mammals who are unrelated to all species of fish), the term for the fish that is used in the public, e.g. in restaurants, is Mahi Mahi.
In biology, "Dorado" is the name of two sorts of fish: a freshwater fish in South America and a predatory fish that lives in the ocean. The ocean inhabitants, who had inspired de Houtman and Keyser, are today known as dolphinfishes with the scientific genus name "Coryphaena". The "Common Dolphinfish" (''Coryphaena hippurus'') is called '''''Mahi Mahi,''''' the Hawaiian language term for "very strong". In Persian, the word "mahi" (ماهی) happens to mean "fish" which is unrelated to the Hawaiian term. Although there are other names for the fish in some regions (e.g. "Lampuka" on the Mediterranean island of Malta and specifically "Ikan Lemadang" in Indonesia, where de Houtman and Keyser invented the celestial name), the Hawaiian term became publicly known. To avoid confusion with dolphins (the sea mammals that are unrelated to all species of fish), the term for the fish that is used in the public, e.g. in restaurants, is Mahi Mahi.


===Modern transformations ===
===Modern transformations ===
The standard topic that Dorado hunts Volans canbe traced throughout history. Yet, Bode and Goldbach show some anomalies: Bode made two books: one in German 1772 as a very young man, training himself in astronomy ("Anleitung zur Kenntniß des gestirnten Himmels") and his famous atlas as senior astronomer at the Berlin observatory, ''Uranographia'' (1801). In 1772, he labels Dorado "swordfish" and in his Latin-labelled atlas consequently "Xiphias" (and not "Dorado" like everybody else). Goldbach (1799) reproduces Lacaille's map but labels it in German with the translation "swordfish" while in his own interpreation of the map (next page), he labels Dorado "goldfish". <gallery>
The standard topic that Dorado hunts Volans can be traced throughout history. Yet, Bode and Goldbach show some anomalies: Bode wrote two books: one in German in 1772 as a very young man, training himself in astronomy ("Anleitung zur Kenntniß des gestirnten Himmels") and his famous atlas as senior astronomer at the Berlin observatory, ''Uranographia'' (1801). In 1772, he labels Dorado "swordfish" and in his Latin-labelled atlas consequently "Xiphias" (and not "Dorado" like everybody else). Goldbach (1799) reproduces Lacaille's map but labels it in German with the translation "swordfish" while in his own interpretation of the map (next page), he labels Dorado "goldfish". <gallery>
File:Dor+vol Bayer1603.jpg|Bayer (1603): Dorado hunts Volans
File:Dor+vol Bayer1603.jpg|Bayer (1603): Dorado hunts Volans
File:Dorado+volans Dopplmayr1742.jpg|Doppelmayr's (1742) version of Dorado's hunt of Volans
File:Dorado+volans Dopplmayr1742.jpg|Doppelmayr's (1742) version of Dorado's hunt of Volans
Line 21: Line 23:
File:Dor+vol+arg Goldbach1799.jpg|Goldbach's own version of Dorado hunting Volans next to Argo (1799)
File:Dor+vol+arg Goldbach1799.jpg|Goldbach's own version of Dorado hunting Volans next to Argo (1799)
File:Dor goldbach1799.jpg|Goldbach's own "Dorado" is labelled "Goldfisch" (goldfish) in German (1799).
File:Dor goldbach1799.jpg|Goldbach's own "Dorado" is labelled "Goldfisch" (goldfish) in German (1799).
File:Simon1894 Dorado+Ret.jpg|Dorado with Reticulum and Pictor at ''Planisferio celeste'' (Carlos Simón 1894)
</gallery>
</gallery>

== IAU Star Name Discussion ==
As the stars of Dorado are rather faint, no one has a proper historical name. The main star is α Dor (3.3 mag) and β Dor has 3.8 mag; all other stars are fainter than 4 mag.

As the official translation of the constellation name should be "Dolphinfish", it might be an idea to name the brightest star (α Dor) Mahi Mahi but we need to make sure that this does not cause conflict with the Hawaiian native speakers and their culture. Several members of the WGSN position themselves against this idea for various reasons, and alternative suggestions have been made, particularly searching for indigenous names for stars and constellations in this area. The name Mahi Mahi was never to our knowledge applied to an asterism, so it may be inappropriate to use this Hawaiian term. The Indonesian term "Ikan Lemadang" is a bit of a mouthful, and not internationally recognised, but it may possibly be more appropriate.

Johnson<ref>Johnson, Rubellite, John Mahelona and Clive Ruggles (in press, publication expected in 2026). ''Nā Inoa Hōkū: Hawaiian and Pacific Star Names'', 3rd edn. Honolulu: University of Hawai‘i Press.</ref> ''et al''.’s Austronesian star catalogue lists the "Dolphin constellation" ''Kailou'' from the Admiralty Is. and the Kankanaey asterism ''Sipat'', both of which are identified with modern Delphinus or possibly Dorado. In other words, it is possible that Dorado was known as Kailou in Melanesia and Sipat in the Malay Archipelago, which leads to the suggestion of Kailou and/ or Sipat for stars in Dorado.

According to Ambrosio<ref>Ambrosio, Dante L. (2010). ''Balatik: Etnoastronomiya Kalangitan sa Kabihasnang Pilipino''. Diliman, Quezon City: University of the Philippines Press.</ref> (2010, 155): "Sipat and Tudong [another asterism] are mentioned in prayers for the offering of a chicken for someone who cannot control urination, and for the ceremony of ''kentan'', where the rice seedlings are blessed before being planted." Vanoverbergh<ref>Vanoverbergh, Morice, "Kankenay Religion", ''Anthropos'' 67 (1972), 72-128.</ref> (1972, 91) identifies Sipat as "The Dolphin" whereas Tudong is "part of Andromeda, Pisces, Triangulum, and Aries". It is pretty clear that the Dolphin in question is Delphinus, not Dorado. "Sipat" in Tagalog does not mean Dolphin but rather "look carefully". It may have other meanings in other Filipino languages, but these are grounds for ruling out this term for stars in Dorado.

Kailou is certainly a fish name in the Manus. Still, it is the wrong type of fish (jack [Carangidae]), (see Akimichi and Sukiyama 2010, 16)<ref>Akimichi, Tomoya and Osamu Sukiyama (2010). ''Manus fish names''. doi.org/10.15021/00004269.</ref> and, once again, the name is more likely to apply to Delphinus rather than Dorado. If we apply "Kailou" here, we probably apply it to the wrong region in the sky.

An alternative candidate name is "''Xiphias''" (swordfish), the alias for the constellation name "Dorado," as it appeared in Kepler's Rudolphine Tables (1627). The name "Xiphias" was also applied to the constellation by Halley (1678), Hevelius (1690), and Bode (1801).

== Weblinks ==

* [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bk7McNUjWgw BBC Earth (youTube) documenting the hunt of flying fish by the dolphinfish].


== References==
== References==

*Ian Ridpath, Star Tales. [http://www.ianridpath.com/startales/dorado.html website]
[[Category:Modern]]
*Frederik de Houtman (1603) [https://objects.library.uu.nl/reader/index.php?obj=1874-205055&lan=en#page//10/65/92/106592907949460216143244254321834124579.jpg/mode/1up Star Catalogue concerning the Indian Magpie]
[[Category:Constellation]]
*Alfred Maass, ``Sternkunde und Sterndeuterei im malaiischen Archipel<nowiki>''</nowiki>, [https://kitlv-docs.library.leiden.edu/open/Metamorfoze/TBG/tbg.html Tijdschrift voor Indische Taal-, Land- en Volkenkunde], vol. 64 (1924), pp. 1-172 & 347-459, with a "Nachtrag", vol. 66 (1926), pp. 618-670.
[[Category:Eurasia]]
[[Category:European]]
[[Category:88 IAU-Constellations]]

Latest revision as of 10:39, 25 September 2024

DOR modern map
The modern map of the IAU-constellation Dorado (S&T graphics)

One of the 88 official constellations. There is no need to translate the term because "Dorado" already is a modern (not Latin) word and used in many languages to designate a specific sort of fish. For further explanation, "Dorado, the Dolphinfish" would work in English. The Spanish term "dorado" literally means "golden", and it has been used for various type of fish in the past. Given this translation, the constellation name has sometimes been translated as "Goldfish", although the Spanish term always designated exotic fish species from the "new worlds".

Etymology and History

Dorado, the Dolphinfish, has been invented by Pieter Keyser and Frederik de Houtman on their journey to Indonesia (later called "Dutch Indies") 1592-1594. Their catalogue[1] of southern stars was published by de Houtman in 1603 as an appendix to a dictionary of the Malaysian (and other) language(s). Before the publication of the star catalogue, de Houtman shared his data with Petrus Plancius, who had actually commissioned this work. Even in the 1590s, Plancius had worked with this material and his celestial globe of 1598 already displayed paintings of the newly invented constellations in the south, and so did Johann Bayer's Uranometria (1603).

Species of Fish

Following Dekker (1987),[2] Ridpath[3] (supported by van Gent) argues that the dorado in the sky hunts the flying fish (Volans), and that the Dutch explorer might have observed such a hunt on their journey (cf. BBC Earth documentation, also see Maas 1924[4]).

Despite translating the Spanish term "dorado" (golden), historical Spanish and other European languages never designated any species of goldfish (small freshwater pet fish) with the term.

In biology, "Dorado" is the name of two sorts of fish: a freshwater fish in South America and a predatory fish that lives in the ocean. The ocean inhabitants, who had inspired de Houtman and Keyser, are today known as dolphinfishes with the scientific genus name "Coryphaena". The "Common Dolphinfish" (Coryphaena hippurus) is called Mahi Mahi, the Hawaiian language term for "very strong". In Persian, the word "mahi" (ماهی) happens to mean "fish" which is unrelated to the Hawaiian term. Although there are other names for the fish in some regions (e.g. "Lampuka" on the Mediterranean island of Malta and specifically "Ikan Lemadang" in Indonesia, where de Houtman and Keyser invented the celestial name), the Hawaiian term became publicly known. To avoid confusion with dolphins (the sea mammals that are unrelated to all species of fish), the term for the fish that is used in the public, e.g. in restaurants, is Mahi Mahi.

Modern transformations

The standard topic that Dorado hunts Volans can be traced throughout history. Yet, Bode and Goldbach show some anomalies: Bode wrote two books: one in German in 1772 as a very young man, training himself in astronomy ("Anleitung zur Kenntniß des gestirnten Himmels") and his famous atlas as senior astronomer at the Berlin observatory, Uranographia (1801). In 1772, he labels Dorado "swordfish" and in his Latin-labelled atlas consequently "Xiphias" (and not "Dorado" like everybody else). Goldbach (1799) reproduces Lacaille's map but labels it in German with the translation "swordfish" while in his own interpretation of the map (next page), he labels Dorado "goldfish".

IAU Star Name Discussion

As the stars of Dorado are rather faint, no one has a proper historical name. The main star is α Dor (3.3 mag) and β Dor has 3.8 mag; all other stars are fainter than 4 mag.

As the official translation of the constellation name should be "Dolphinfish", it might be an idea to name the brightest star (α Dor) Mahi Mahi but we need to make sure that this does not cause conflict with the Hawaiian native speakers and their culture. Several members of the WGSN position themselves against this idea for various reasons, and alternative suggestions have been made, particularly searching for indigenous names for stars and constellations in this area. The name Mahi Mahi was never to our knowledge applied to an asterism, so it may be inappropriate to use this Hawaiian term. The Indonesian term "Ikan Lemadang" is a bit of a mouthful, and not internationally recognised, but it may possibly be more appropriate.

Johnson[5] et al.’s Austronesian star catalogue lists the "Dolphin constellation" Kailou from the Admiralty Is. and the Kankanaey asterism Sipat, both of which are identified with modern Delphinus or possibly Dorado. In other words, it is possible that Dorado was known as Kailou in Melanesia and Sipat in the Malay Archipelago, which leads to the suggestion of Kailou and/ or Sipat for stars in Dorado.

According to Ambrosio[6] (2010, 155): "Sipat and Tudong [another asterism] are mentioned in prayers for the offering of a chicken for someone who cannot control urination, and for the ceremony of kentan, where the rice seedlings are blessed before being planted." Vanoverbergh[7] (1972, 91) identifies Sipat as "The Dolphin" whereas Tudong is "part of Andromeda, Pisces, Triangulum, and Aries". It is pretty clear that the Dolphin in question is Delphinus, not Dorado. "Sipat" in Tagalog does not mean Dolphin but rather "look carefully". It may have other meanings in other Filipino languages, but these are grounds for ruling out this term for stars in Dorado.

Kailou is certainly a fish name in the Manus. Still, it is the wrong type of fish (jack [Carangidae]), (see Akimichi and Sukiyama 2010, 16)[8] and, once again, the name is more likely to apply to Delphinus rather than Dorado. If we apply "Kailou" here, we probably apply it to the wrong region in the sky.

An alternative candidate name is "Xiphias" (swordfish), the alias for the constellation name "Dorado," as it appeared in Kepler's Rudolphine Tables (1627). The name "Xiphias" was also applied to the constellation by Halley (1678), Hevelius (1690), and Bode (1801).

Weblinks

References

  1. de Houtman, Frederik (1603) Star Catalogue in a Dictionary of Malayan language
  2. Dekker, E. (1987), Early explorations of the southern celestial sky, Annals of Science, 44:5, 439-470. PDF here References (Medieval and Early Modern)
  3. Ridpath, Ian * Ridpath, Ian, Star Tales: online edition.
  4. Maass, Alfred, ``Sternkunde und Sterndeuterei im malaiischen Archipel'', Tijdschrift voor Indische Taal-, Land- en Volkenkunde, vol. 64 (1924), pp. 1-172 & 347-459, with a "Nachtrag", vol. 66 (1926), pp. 618-670.
  5. Johnson, Rubellite, John Mahelona and Clive Ruggles (in press, publication expected in 2026). Nā Inoa Hōkū: Hawaiian and Pacific Star Names, 3rd edn. Honolulu: University of Hawai‘i Press.
  6. Ambrosio, Dante L. (2010). Balatik: Etnoastronomiya Kalangitan sa Kabihasnang Pilipino. Diliman, Quezon City: University of the Philippines Press.
  7. Vanoverbergh, Morice, "Kankenay Religion", Anthropos 67 (1972), 72-128.
  8. Akimichi, Tomoya and Osamu Sukiyama (2010). Manus fish names. doi.org/10.15021/00004269.